the site for digicams review Dorthonion has mentioned is really comprehensive (I had checked it for days aside this one
http://www.dcresource.com/ before buying my nikon(which is now an old large model and looks like D-SLR
so here some further criteria from me:
- 'shutter' speed is only important if you want to capture spontanous/moving elements.
- I also find the time important it takes before the camera is ready. this is the most annoying thing with digicams...
- I find the movable/turnable LCD at some nikon cameras so handy, I wouldn't want a camera without it anymore. (also the formed kind of handle makes it easy to hold or walking in hand with it. I've never used bands/ribbons with cameras)
- minimum distortion at the pic edges
- good white balance
- good colours/colour relations (though I know how to correct pics in Photoshop I want a good original)
- sharpness also at extreme zooming/enlargements (no edges with blue/red/white overlaying)
- I prefer large zoom (8 or 10x) to size/weight (not important for me as I usually carry a backpack with me)
- fast recharging batteries (I have 4)
- as one has to invest in additional batteries and memory cards this also might determine the brand (or staying with a brand)
what I miss at the nikon is a sort of optional grid in the LCD screen to get pics exactly straight for panoramas.
there a many more considerations...
as you say, have a try at somebody elses camera to define your criteria furthermore