What happens if a scenario is good vs good or evil vs evil and, in a fight, the rolls and fight values are drawn?
Which side is 1,2,3, and which side is 4,5,6?

Also, what happens if both sides have elven blades? Do they just cancell each other out?


Thanks,
LordElrond

We weren't sure about the first question, so, in the game, we just rolled again.

You have to decide who will be representing evil and who will be representing good at the beginning of the game, which ever is most logical and if you can't decide roll on it.

And yes two elven blades cancel each other out

_________________
http://grungehog.blogspot.co.uk/

What about in a 3 way battle?

In a 3 way have each player roll off against one another if an elf blade is involved.

And just add 1 to the dice score of the elf blade guy?

Easily solved: one side rolls the dice, the other calls the result. There's no need to be strictly RAW about a rule like that, we always play good vs evil and that's how we resolve it.



That seems fair. Or each player could roll, and the two highest scores then roll off normally for winning the Duel.

If you are fighting blue v blue, I would say whoever has priority counts as good. So whoever has priority is the one that rolls the tie dice, so they would win on a 4+, 3+ is they have an elven blade.

_________________
"Leave Sauron to me."
If you're in the Raleigh, NC area, let me know.

We just agree at the start who is "evil" or "good".
So 1-3 "evil" good, 4-6 "good" good

Then when an elven blade is involved the rulebook already has the answers.
In the hobbit rulebook.
If evil has it then 1-4
If good has it 3-6
IF both then it cancels out

In a 3 way battle... I scream n run away.